How to Cook Fresh Local Shrimp: Buying, Peeling and Five Simple Methods
Few things say late summer on the Grand Strand like a bag of fresh shrimp from a local seafood market. Many rental kitchens are simple, but shrimp do not need much. With good shrimp and a few basics, you can make a meal that rivals any restaurant on the strand.
Buying shrimp the local way
Seafood markets along the coast, from Little River and Murrells Inlet to the markets along US 17, often sell shrimp caught by area boats when they are in season. A few tips:
- Ask where they came from. A good market will tell you whether shrimp are local, domestic or imported.
- Know the count. Shrimp are sold by size, described as a count per pound. Lower numbers mean bigger shrimp.
- Heads on or off. Heads-on shrimp are often a bit cheaper per pound and many cooks swear they taste sweeter, but you lose some weight when you remove the heads.
- Use your nose. Fresh shrimp should smell like clean saltwater, not like ammonia.
Storing and prepping
Keep shrimp cold. Put them on ice in the refrigerator as soon as you get back to the rental and plan to cook them within a day or two. To peel, pull off the head if attached, then the legs and shell. To devein, run a small knife along the back and lift out the dark vein. Some people leave the shell on for boiling and grilling, since it protects the meat and adds flavor.
Five simple ways to cook them
1. Boiled and chilled. Bring well-seasoned water to a boil, add shrimp in their shells and cook just until they turn pink and curl, usually only a couple of minutes. Drain and chill on ice. Serve with cocktail sauce or remoulade.
2. Sauteed with garlic and butter. Melt butter with olive oil in a skillet, add garlic, then peeled shrimp. Cook until pink, finish with lemon juice and parsley, and serve over rice or with crusty bread.
3. Grilled skewers. Toss peeled shrimp in oil, salt, pepper and a little smoked paprika. Thread onto skewers and grill briefly on each side. Brush with lemon butter at the end.
4. Shrimp and grits. A Lowcountry classic. Cook stone-ground grits slowly with butter and a little cheese. Separately, crisp some bacon or sausage, saute shrimp in the drippings with onion and pepper, add a splash of stock, and spoon over the grits.
5. Fried shrimp. Dredge peeled shrimp in seasoned flour or cornmeal, fry in hot oil until golden, and drain. Rental kitchens without a thermometer can make this tricky, so work in small batches and be careful with hot oil.
The one rule
Do not overcook. Shrimp go from tender to rubbery quickly. As a general guide, cook them until they are opaque and pink and curled into a loose C. A tight O often means they went too long. Pull them a moment early and let residual heat finish the job.
Leftover shrimp make an excellent next-day salad with celery, mayonnaise, lemon and a dash of seafood seasoning. Pile it on a soft roll and take it to the beach in a cooler for an easy, very coastal lunch.
A Shrimp Night Game Plan
Good shrimp dinners are mostly about timing. Here is a simple plan for a rental kitchen that keeps things relaxed:
- Shop in the afternoon. Buy shrimp the day you plan to cook them if possible, and bring a cooler with ice for the drive back.
- Prep while the sides cook. Start the rice, grits or potatoes first. Peel and devein the shrimp while those cook, or set up a peeling station for the group.
- Dry the shrimp. Pat peeled shrimp dry with paper towels. Dry shrimp brown better and splatter less.
- Season just before cooking. Salt and spices draw moisture out of shrimp if they sit too long.
- Cook last. Since shrimp cook in minutes, they should be the final thing to hit the heat. Have plates, sauces and sides ready.
- Serve right away. Shrimp are best hot off the stove or grill, or fully chilled for cold preparations.
Sauces and Seasonings That Work in Any Rental
A few simple sauces can turn the same bag of shrimp into several different meals over the week:
- Quick cocktail sauce: Ketchup, prepared horseradish, lemon juice and a dash of hot sauce. Adjust the horseradish to taste.
- Simple remoulade-style sauce: Mayonnaise, a spoonful of mustard, a little hot sauce, lemon juice, chopped pickles or relish and a pinch of seafood seasoning.
- Lemon butter: Melted butter, lemon juice, garlic and parsley. Brush on grilled shrimp or use as a dipping sauce.
- Spicy dry rub: Paprika, garlic powder, onion powder, a little cayenne, salt and pepper. Toss with oil and shrimp before grilling or searing.
- Bright herb sauce: Chopped parsley or cilantro, olive oil, garlic, lemon or lime juice and a pinch of salt.
Common Shrimp Mistakes in a Rental Kitchen
Crowding the pan. Too many shrimp in one skillet will steam instead of sear. Cook in batches if needed.
Thawing on the counter. If you buy frozen shrimp, thaw them in the refrigerator or in a bowl of cold water, not at room temperature.
Skipping the salt in boiling water. Unsalted water leaves shrimp bland. The water should taste well seasoned.
Forgetting the skewers soak. Wooden skewers can burn on the grill. Soak them in water before threading shrimp, or use metal skewers.
Leaving shells in the kitchen trash. Shells and heads smell fast in warm weather. Bag them tightly and take them outside right away.
Shrimp Questions Home Cooks Ask
Do I have to devein shrimp?
It is largely a matter of preference and appearance, especially with smaller shrimp. Many cooks devein larger shrimp because the vein can be gritty.
Can I save the shells?
Yes. Simmer shells and heads with water, onion and a bay leaf for a quick seafood stock to use in grits, rice or soup.
How many shrimp should I buy?
It depends on appetites and the rest of the meal. Ask the market staff for a suggestion based on your group and the size of the shrimp.
What if someone has a shellfish allergy?
Shellfish allergies can be serious. Cook separate dishes in clean pans with clean utensils, and keep shrimp and their cooking liquid away from anyone who is allergic.






